How could I know? Packed into a one-story rancher that my buddy and his wife were renting in their first-year of marriage, Super Bowl XLIII was ticking down on the big screen, and John Madden was putting a bow on the big game. HIs last bow, his last game. We had no idea. Those final few moments with Madden were to be the last game we got to share with him.
I didn’t get to appreciate Madden for the bulk of his career, but when I did start watching the NFL intently, he was a significant part of that experience. Hell, even my Mom loved Madden. Last week I highlighted my Top 5 play-by-play callers. This week I shifted to the other half of the booth – the color guys. Looks like I gave away the number one spot with this intro, as Madden was the master at providing context, insights, humor, and pulling you in, and bringing you along for the ride. Here are the top five color commentators who’ve made a mark on my watching experience.
5) Greg Olsen
That was quick. Olsen stepped in and it seemed like by Week 3 of his first season he was near the top of this list. After a standout tight end career, he joined FOX’s top broadcast team and quickly was one of the best analysts in the game. His ability to break down complex plays in a way that’s digestible for casual fans but still valuable for hardcore football enthusiasts has been impressive. Also had to completely respect the way he handled being demoted when Tom Brady signed that massive broadcast deal with FOX, sending him to the B team
4) Don Meredith
The legend. Hey, I wasn’t alive when Don was doing his thing, it was long before my day, but I’ve watched enough Youtube clips with my Dad and friends to know what Dandy Don brought to the game. I use the word “legend” very intentionally. He oozed charm, wit and could get the audience, and his colleagues laughing along. His dynamic with Howard Cosell and Frank Gifford was groundbreaking, blending football analysis with entertainment in a way that made Monday Night Football the brand it is today.
3) Troy Aikman
Troy’s Hall of Fame career as a quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys, and three Super Bowl rings was the foundation for what has become a broadcast career that will nab him another Hall-of-Fame nod. Obviously he has the experience and knowledge, but what I love is he never tries to overshadow the game. Humility, humor, and expert commentary that focuses on the big picture.
2) Cris Collinsworth
Cris Collinsworth is, without a doubt, IMHO the best active color commentator in the NFL. His ability to analyze the game is unmatched, whether he’s dissecting a blocking scheme or calling out a defensive lapse. Collinsworth’s candid style, combined with his knack for storytelling, makes every broadcast richer.
- John Madden
See above. There is no analyst more iconic than John Madden. After a legendary coaching career, Madden entered the booth and forever changed how football was presented on television. He brought unparalleled energy, humor, and a deep love for the game.
And of course, his contributions extended far beyond the booth. The All-Madden team and the Madden NFL video game franchise introduced generations to the game. Madden’s influence on the game, both on and off the field, is immeasurable, making him the gold standard.
Plays
Last Week: 2-1 ATS
Season Record: 18-9 ATS
College
North Carolina vs. Boston College
Coach O’Brien made that QB switch a couple of weeks ago, and while Grayson James stumbled a bit last week vs. SMU, the change should pay dividends this week. The Tar Heels are on a winning streak, and are now bowl eligible with six wins. Exciting times for UNC. Meanwhile, BC is trying to secure that eligibility, sitting at 5-5. I like the Eagles to be able to move the ball, both through the air and on the ground, and be too much for this small road favorite, who accomplished a big goal with their win last week. Small letdown spot for them.
Play: I’ve played Boston College +2.5
Penn State vs. Minnesota
I’ve been off and on Penn State all season, and am still not sure this team should be ranked as high as they are, but I get it. They join three other Big 10 schools in the Top 5 (that’s wild), but we could see Indiana slip out with a loss vs. Ohio State (or who knows, an Indiana upset will shift things up as well). That off and on part I mentioned above, well this week I’m off. I like Minny in this spot. They have the team to keep it close. Getting over 10 points in what should be a battle, I’m on the home underdog.
Play: I’m taking Minnesota +11
NFL
Ravens at Chargers
Baltimore is coming off arguably their worst offensive performance of the season vs. the Steelers. They couldn’t convert third downs, didn’t establish their running game, and Lamar was rather ordinary. Their pass defense is still bad, nothing’s changed on that side, but I fully expect the offense to get some things sorted, even facing a good defense (despite some stats, they are not the best defense in the league). The Chargers went all Chargers last week and blew a three TD lead to almost lose vs. the Bengals. They’ll get pushed again. I’m expecting Jackson, Henry and the rest of the offense to have a big day, and come away with a win.
Play: I’m taking the Ravens -2.5
Join me over at the Winner’s Edge Patreon (it’s free) for more college and NFL picks.